I ordered a long sleeve top in Large and it fits perfectly - sleeve length, overall length - spot on! This, however, was made using completely different measurements. The sleeve length was clearly made for a Hobbit, not normal people. TBF I am 6'4" with long arms, but if one item fits why doesn't another of the same size?! I'm going to try an XL as the hoody itself is well made, just the sizing seems out of step with other lines. If you're thinking of buying one and you're not related to Bilbo, go a size up.

Another purchase in the sale but again no complaints; the recent weather hasn't allowed me to wear it much but the times i have i've really like it!